WHO FARTED? Review
A straight take on Badass Experiences’ 1-vs-all fart deduction party game—no fake aggregate scores.
Review setup (no fake Metacritic)
This is an editorial review for the Roblox experience WHO FARTED? by Badass Experiences (Josh_ua), place 115668616082195. It is not a paid placement and not a scraped Metacritic / OpenCritic number. We score categories in plain language so you can decide whether to spend an evening—and optionally 599 Robux on 2x Farter Chance.
Snapshot context (moves daily): launched 26 August 2026, updated as recently as 18 September 2026, on the order of ~1.03M visits, roughly ~2.3k CCU at research peaks, 5477 favorites, max about 10 players. Pitch: one secret farter; find them before you get farted on. Survival / 1 vs All energy with party-game jokes.
Who it is for
Great fit if you like:
- Short social deduction rounds with friends (Play with Friends)
- Meme-forward lobbies where chat matters as much as movement
- Alternating hunter and town mindsets in the same session
- Low barrier cosmetics like the free fart skin
Weak fit if you want:
- Deep progression trees, ranked seasons, or long campaign lore
- Huge maps with complex task lists
- Single-player offline modes
- A polished esports ruleset on day thirty of a brand-new place
If you are brand new, skim Getting Started before judging the genre from one tilted lobby.
Score-style sections
Ratings use a simple Excellent / Good / Mixed / Rough label—not a fake 0–100 aggregate.
Hook and fantasy — Excellent
The premise is instantly readable to anyone who has played “find the hidden troublemaker” party games. The joke title filters for players who want silly tension, which is a feature: you waste less time explaining the bit.
Match length and lobby size — Good
A ~10 player cap keeps accusations personal. You can learn names and outfits. Sparse servers feel swingy; full servers feel properly chaotic. Queue quality depends on CCU peaks more than on any hidden MMR.
Social deduction depth — Good (with caveats)
There is real room for pathing reads, vote timing, and decoy work—see Find the Farter, Win as Farter, and the Suspicion Tracker. Public documentation is still thin on exact ability sheets, so skill expression is more social than mechanical spreadsheet. That will delight vibe players and frustrate theorycrafters.
Onboarding and rewards — Good
Like + group for a free cosmetic is clear. The WIN AS FARTER badge (Badges) gives hunters a trophy. No promo codes yet (Codes), which is fine for a young game but means codes hunters should set expectations. The 599 Robux GamePass is optional practice fuel, not a pay-to-win shield.
Humor and tone — Mixed to Good
If fart jokes wear out in five minutes, leave. If they do not, the tone matches the title. Developer notes like “removed kanye” (Updates) show active iteration and meme willingness—also a reminder that gag assets can vanish.
Fairness and toxicity — Mixed
Friend stacks and private Discord can stomp public lobbies when groups refuse fair-play norms. That is a genre problem as much as a this-game problem; our Play with Friends page exists because sportsmanship matters in 10-person servers. Scripts scene: none trustworthy found; treat executor ads as hostile (Scripts).
Value for money — Good if free-to-play first
The base loop costs zero Robux. Spend only after you know you like hunter reps. Review the pass math on 2x Farter Chance before impulse buying.
Longevity — Mixed (early days)
At roughly a month old (created late August 2026), longevity depends on Badass Experiences shipping maps, tools, or events players care about. Watch Discord and @Joshua_Badass. A million visits with solid CCU is a healthy start, not a finished content roadmap.
Comparison: Among Us energy
Similar: Hidden threat, public discussion, vote pressure, friend-stack drama, short rounds.
Different: WHO FARTED? leans harder into joke branding and 1-vs-all party framing than task-heavy crewmate chores. Do not expect a 1:1 meeting UI clone. Skills transfer (do not tunnel on vibes; force second reasons; track pathing), but guides for Among Us maps will mislead you here.
Comparison: “Find who slapped” / slap-secret genre
Roblox periodically cycles secret-role slap, bite, or prank games. WHO FARTED? sits in that neighborhood: identify the culprit before the gag lands. If you enjoyed those loops, the learning curve is mostly social calibration—not a new genre class. Use our tier list for approach ranking rather than importing another game’s character tiers.
Pros
- Instantly understandable fantasy
- Small lobbies where one good callout matters
- Free cosmetic onboarding path
- Clear hunter trophy badge
- Active enough CCU for quick queues at peak
- Optional GamePass that is honest about “more odds,” not “auto win”
Cons
- Joke tone is polarizing
- Thin public mechanical documentation
- Stack abuse can sour publics
- Early-product rough edges and gag removals
- No codes loop for reward hunters yet
- Easy to confuse with unrelated fart-titled games on other platforms
Final recommendation
Play it if you want a short, loud social deduction snack with friends or randoms who can take a joke. Start free, learn both roles, then decide on Robux. Skip or wait if you need deep progression, hate toilet humor, or only chase code listicles.
Practical next steps: Getting Started, Guides hub, Roles, and official links. Join Discord if you want group nights done right.
Related pages
Frequently Asked Questions
Quick answers to the most common questions.
Is WHO FARTED? worth playing in 2026?
Yes as a free party deduction snack if you like meme lobbies and short rounds. Try before buying the GamePass.
Is this the same as Among Us?
Same broad hidden-threat energy, different branding and systems. Transfer social habits, not map guides.
Do I need to spend Robux?
No. The free skin and natural farter rolls are enough to judge the game. Pass details: 2x Farter Chance.
Why does this review lack a Metacritic score?
We do not invent aggregate scores. Category labels above are editorial, not a scraped critic average.
Where should I go after reading the review?
Getting Started if you will play; Updates if you are waiting on content.